• hey scoble: why i don't like MOV

    i'm on a few conference calls today and planned on doing some peripheral learning.  there were a few interesting things over at lately that i found intriguing and wanted to watch.  i went to the site and was disappointed.  why...well let me phrase this appropriately :-)

    i have a brand new windows vista machine.  loaded (fill-in-your-favorite-browser) on it.  visited scobleshow and clicked on a "watch now" link.  this is what it looked like:

    Scobleshow MOV format only

    why did i get this?  because scobleshow only enables MOV format (arguably the intended viewer is Quicktime format -- which i hate).  so as a user i'm unable to view this unless i download quicktime (or another plugin that isn't recognized automatically).  i should note that when viewed in firefox, there was at least a message indicating that i have missing plugins.  the size of the missing "plugin" (aka quicktime) is 18MB according to the quicktime player link i clicked on.  ouch...flash plugin?  i have no idea but it loaded in about 4 seconds for me (loaded = dowloaded+installed+started working).  this is why i hate quicktime -- it isn't a plugin -- it's a friggin application and a hog.

    of course i could download a quicktime plugin that is light-weight, but that's me -- i'm a power user...i know about it.  my mother-in-law doesn't know any better and will always accept the default.  this is who we need to design for--the least common denominator.  okay, sure my mother-in-law then is likely not viewing scobleshow, but what if i find something interesting (ahem, scrapblog) that she might like and send her a link...now she is a consumer.

    so why am i picking on scoble?

    from a post "Why I don't use Flash":

    "I have a brand new Windows Vista machine. Loaded Firefox on it. And visited PodShow (a podcasting competitor of PodTech’s).

    This is what it looked like. Now, if a “normal” person (non geek) hit this site, what would they do? I’ll tell you what they’ll do. They’ll hit back and get out of there. Note the title tag. Be Patient? No, I click that little green back button and leave before I get hurt. Thank you very much. Have a nice day.

    Lesson: always have HTML first before you get to Flash content."

    :-)  sooo robert?  what are you going to do?  what could the site have done better?  offer options?  offer some html about the viewer needed?  if so, can you please ask yourself those questions and change your way of thinking for scobleshow?  why not use a flash viewer -- it's almost default installed.  oh you want higher quality and that's why you use MOV format?  hmmm...soapbox seems to have gotten it right.  oh, you want widescreen format?  why?  is your content "widescreen-capable" (meaning: is there a reason for widescreen?  i mean, apologies and all, but i'm not watching scobleshow on my 60" HDTV with surround sound -- so i don't need it)?  oh you want to deliver HD content?  hmm...okay, but what about those who wouldn't be able to consume it -- again, give me options.

    so scoble, i beg of you: 1) fix the page to show some warning; 2) give me a default player for the "watch now"; 3) show me options (look at how your previous employer gives me download options on each show); 4) do something to reach the masses.  right now i'm unable to enjoy the content.

    Monday, October 23, 2006 10:42 AM

    PostTypeIcon

Comments.

  • Gravatar
    # re: hey scoble: why i don't like MOV


    I don't install QuickTime. So I've never seen the Scobble show. Sorry Robby. No movie is that important. Seriously.

    I do install Flash, but think that's mostly to be able to play the occasional free online game -- not the cheesy web content.

    Cameron

    10/28/2006 8:25 AM
  • Gravatar
    # re: hey scoble: why i don't like MOV


    Absolutely agreed. About On10.net: Microsoft has a multi-million-dollar video studio that can do multiple formats and millions of dollars in funding. I didn't even have a machine capable of video until last week.

    As to Flash. I'm considering that too, but it simply doesn't look as good.

    As for widescreen. Widescreen is a nicer-looking format. I'll put up some comparisons sometime, but I really want to stick with the 16:9 format that my HD camera films in if possible.

    But, more formats are coming as soon as my new editor starts, which will be in mid-November.

    10/23/2006 11:33 AM
  • timheuer said:
    Gravatar
    # re: hey scoble: why i don't like MOV


    @robert: glad to hear changes are coming! but even without millions of dollars (maybe i should move to that group :-)), i use camtasia and can import various formats and output a great player (google video-esque) with my-determined quality video -- so put the crappy video in an online video player with flash and make it "download for greater resolution"

    10/23/2006 11:51 AM
  • Gravatar
    # re: hey scoble: why i don't like MOV


    You need quicktime killer!!
    http://geekswithblogs.net/thibbard/archive/2005/03/21/26851.aspx

    10/23/2006 1:36 PM

Your Reply.

  Comment Form  

Fields denoted with a "*" are required.

*Your name:
Subject:
Your blog:
Your email:  (will not be displayed)
*Your message:

 
Please add 8 and 1 and type the answer here: