Advertisement

travel rant: whomever came up with the 3oz rule is an idiot

it's been a few weeks since i've been on a plane...my last trip i had a bag big enough i needed to check anyway, so i paid no attention to the liquid restriction for myself -- although the warning signs were all over.

well, the tsa has 'loosened the restrictions' on liquids.  again, i have to ask the question of what research/tactic/preventative mechanism is now in place that makes the tsa confident that the problem is solved?  i worried when they first made the restriction that it would not be able to be revoked.  well, i stand corrected (sort of).  apparently there is a magic number of 3 ounces that makes it safe.  granted you can take AS MANY 3OZ ITEMS AS YOU WANT as long as they fit in a provided zip loc bag.  so, by the looks of the bag, i figured you could squeeze about 10 3oz containers in there (size varrying)...so 30 ounces of liquid.  now is that too much?  we'll never know because it is allowed.

the 3oz restriction is lame.  i understand the situation, and i can appreciate being safe...heck i'm not saying i don't want to be safe, but let's put some thought into this.  reducing the amount of liquid to a specific size, but not the overall amount is dumb, just dumb.  i mean, i'm not going to go through the scenarios, but i'm sure you could imagine it just doesn't make sense -- you should either allow them or not.

and if you do have the restrictions, empower the tsa to put some thought into it.  i had my deodorant...it is gel.  so i decided to get one of those plastic bags for me deo, contact lens solution, toothpaste, etc.  the tsa rep looked at my deodorant and said that it is not allowed (the container read 4oz).  i was quick to point out that clearly it was half way gone.  his response: "we can't measure items."  my interpretation: we're not being empowerd to look at a full container and determine that it is half gone and do the math.

that, my friends, is idiotic.

  1. 11/6/2006 10:27 AM | # re: travel rant: whomever came up with the 3oz rule is an idiot
    I went through O'Hare recently, and saw a man getting grief from the TSA over this new rule. It wasn't that he had items over three ounces, or that he didn't have them in a bag.

    He was detained because he had them in the wrong bag. He used a one gallon-sized ziploc instead of the one quart size.

    Stupid, stupid, stupid.
  2. 11/6/2006 11:12 AM | # re: travel rant: whomever came up with the 3oz rule is an idiot
    I just accept now that I will need to check a bag, period. I don't want to jump through more hoops already for the sake of my toothpaste when I'm already having to remove my jacket, shoes, and belt, empty the pockets, unload the laptop, dispose of any drinks, and do a pirouette before walking through the metal detectors and hoping I didn't forget to do something.

    They want you to think it's somehow important or necessary for security but it's complete bullshit. Someone wanting to strike at the US could do so any number of ways without getting on a plane, and ultimately we can't stop them without putting everyone in cages.
  3. 11/7/2006 3:43 PM | # re: travel rant: whomever came up with the 3oz rule is an idiot
    Here is my problem...what the TSA has done is only the "apperance" of security only.

    If you even mention anything to these guys when you are passing through they will make comments to the effect that you support terrorism.

 
Please add 4 and 6 and type the answer here:
First time here? You are looking at the most recent posts. You may also want to check out older archives. Please leave a comment, ask a question and consider subscribing to the latest posts via RSS or email. Thank you for visiting! (hide this)